Highlights
from the Oncology Nursing Society's 10th National Conference
on Cancer Nursing Research
Held February 12-14, 2009, Orlando, Fla
ORLANDO,
FLA—For the more than 2 million breast cancer survivors in
the United States, improved treatments have prolonged life
at the cost of some unpleasant side effects. Among them, the
cognitive changes known as “chemo brain” may be the most
upsetting.
“Cognitive
dysfunction is a significant problem,” affirmed Diane Von
Ah, PhD, RN, an assistant professor in adult health at the
Indiana University School of Nursing, estimating that the
problem affects up to 83% of breast cancer patients. “It's
prevalent, bothersome to women, and can be potentially
debilitating and impact their quality of life.”
Dr Von Ah told meeting attendees that because the etiology
of cognitive dysfunction is not known, the condition is
difficult to treat. However, she suspects there are a number
of underlying factors, and researched the relationship
between serotonin and “chemo brain” based on the direct
relationship between the neurotransmitter and estrogen.
Estrogen withdrawal is a consequence of breast cancer
treatment.
The double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover trial
employed acute tryptophan depletion therapy. Because
tryptophan is a precursor to serotonin, alterations in
tryptophan levels will affect serotonin. The intervention
group received a higher dose of an amino acid to deplete
tryptophan compared to the control group (100% vs 25%).
Participants completed neuropsychological testing 5 hours
after administration of the amino acid, at the tryptophan
nadir. Women in the intervention group were depleted 85% by
hour 5, and the control had a 49% reduction in tryptophan.
Twenty women completed the study.
“We did not find a significant impact on short-term
memory, but we did in long-term memory,” said Dr Von Ah.
The team also found changes in motor function in the
dominant and nondominant hands during the tryptophan
depletion, but no significant changes to attention,
concentration, executive function, or information processing
speed.
The responses did not vary for antiestrogen use,
antidepressant use, treatment protocols, or genetic factors.
There were no significant differences in mood or blood sugar
between the groups.
“In our study, we found that serotonin may be involved in
memory consolidation and psychomotor ability,” stated Dr
Von Ah. “We need to do further research to fully
understand the protective role of serotonin in cognitive
dysfunction, so we can do more with potentially novel
treatment therapies, either pharmacologically or
behaviorally through diet.”
Dr Von Ah presented a second study in which she investigated
self-reported cognitive dysfunction and quality of life in
African-American and Caucasian breast cancer survivors in a
descriptive, correlational study of secondary data from a
larger quality-of-life study. The sample included 134 women
(46% African American and 54% Caucasian) 1-10 years
postdiagnosis.
More than 1 in 4 survivors (26%) reported poor attention,
indicating that cognitive dysfunction can continue long
after treatment. Deficits in capacity to direct attention
correlated with poorer quality of life, including more
depressive symptoms, lower sense of overall wellbeing, less
social support, lower parental satisfaction, poorer physical
functioning, and greater fatigue. Younger women had more
attention problems, depression, and fatigue.
African-American women had decreased social support and
decreased levels of physical function. Women with increased
comorbidities had increased depression, increased fatigue,
and decreased well-being.
“Capacity to direct attention was related to poorer
quality-of-life outcomes, suggesting interventions may have
a broad impact on quality of life in breast cancer
survivors,” summarized Dr Von Ah.
Joyce Thielen, PhD, RN, CS, associate director of
undergraduate studies at Elms College in Chicopee, Mass,
said women undergoing breast cancer chemotherapy frequently
report changes in memory, executive function, organization,
and multitasking abilities, yet subjective testing often
does not correlate with the degree of severity patients are
indicating. She conducted a qualitative study to better
understand 13 women's experiences and what it meant to them.
She found the cognitive changes often were insidious and the
women many times blamed them on menopause, lack of sleep, or
early Alzheimer's disease.
“They looked inside for answers to the attention problems
they were having,” Dr Thielen explained.
The women reported an inability to read or to “keep their
eye on the ball,” or had trouble working. The women also
indicated difficulty driving or correctly taking
medications. Family support helped them cope. They reported
that nurses and doctors dismissed their cognitive
complaints.
“It's important to discuss side effects with patients and
families,” Dr Thielen said. “The assessment needs to be
at time of initial treatment and ongoing to pick up subtle
changes that may develop.”
Dr Thielen also encouraged educating nursing students as
well as nurses about “chemo brain” and the inclusion of
neurocognitive measurements in clinical trials.
Catherine Jansen PhD, RN, OCN, an oncology clinical nurse
specialist at Kaiser Permanente Medical Center, San
Francisco, investigated cognitive function prior to
chemotherapy, whether it changes over time, and its
relationship with anxiety, depression, fatigue, anemia,
menopausal status, and the patient's perception of cognitive
functioning. The prospective trial included 71 women
receiving Adriamycin (doxorubicin) and cyclophosphamide (AC)
or AC followed by a taxane. Participants completed multiple
validated tests.
Preliminary results showed no significant changes in
immediate memory, language, attention, executive function,
and motor skills. However a significant effect of time was
found for visuospatial skill, attention, and delayed memory.
Significant changes in cognitive function remained when
researchers controlled for anxiety, depression, fatigue, and
hemoglobin levels.
