Novel approaches to preventing chemotherapy-induced
cognitive dysfunction in breast cancer: the art of the possible.
Clin Breast
Cancer. 2002 Dec;3 Suppl 3:S121-7. Review.
PMID: 12533273 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Chemotherapy-induced
cognitive dysfunction in women with breast cancer has become an
increasingly important clinical issue. To date, little is known
about its incidence, exact characteristics, and exact
pathophysiology. Likewise, no treatments have been shown to
prevent or decrease cognitive changes thought to result from
chemotherapy. However, ongoing scientific research might help us
understand the mechanisms that will help patients maintain maximal
cognitive function. Changes in cognition due to chemotherapy might
result from indirect chemical toxicity and oxidative damage,
direct injury to neurons, inflammation, or a type of autoimmune
response. Based on these potential causes, and based on
interventions that have been tested in dementia and Alzheimer's
disease, there are a number of potential, novel interventions that
could be tested in clinical trials as treatments for
chemotherapy-induced cognitive dysfunction. Possible anecdotal
strategies to consider include hormonal interventions,
antioxidants, monoamine oxidase inhibitors, growth factors,
dopamine agonists, cholinesterase inhibitors, antiinflammatory
agents, and behavioral interventions
Mayo
Clinic, Division of Medical Oncology, Rochester, MN 55905,
USA.
O'Shaughnessy
JA.
Effects of epoetin alfa on cognitive function, mood,
asthenia, and quality of life in women with breast cancer
undergoing adjuvant chemotherapy.
Clin Breast
Cancer. 2002 Dec;3 Suppl 3:S116-20. Review.
PMID: 12533272 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Several
recently published studies describe moderate to severe cognitive
dysfunction in breast cancer survivors who were treated with
adjuvant chemotherapy 1-5 years before undergoing extensive
neuropsychological testing. While these studies are
hypothesis-generating and preliminary given their small size and
retrospective nature, they consistently suggest that between
approximately 15% and 25% of chemotherapy-treated breast cancer
patients will have evidence of cognitive dysfunction some years
after chemotherapy, compared to about 10% of breast cancer
survivors who did not receive chemotherapy. Recent preclinical
data strongly suggest that erythropoetin is a potent, endogenous
neuroprotective agent that prevents neuronal apoptosis from a
variety of insults including hypoxia, trauma, subarachnoidal
hemorrhage, and encephalitis. Erythropoietin also appears to
enhance learning in a mouse spatial learning maze model. We have
conducted a pilot study of epoetin alfa versus placebo in
early-stage breast cancer patients who received standard adjuvant
anthracycline-based chemotherapy to determine the feasibility of
administering standardized neurocognitive assessment tests in the
oncology practice setting in order to understand whether the
Executive Interview 25 test can detect the subtle cognitive
impairment in verbal fluency, attention, and short-term memory
observed with chemotherapy, and to assess whether epoetin alfa-treated
patients have less evidence of cognitive dysfunction during and 6
months after chemotherapy compared with control-treated patients.
We report here the preliminary results of this pilot clinical
trial.
Baylor
Sammons Cancer Center, US Oncology, Dallas, Texas 75246, USA.
Joyce.O'Shaughnessy@USOncology.com
Schagen
SB, Muller MJ, Boogerd W, Van Dam FS.
Cognitive dysfunction and chemotherapy:
neuropsychological findings in perspective.
Clin Breast
Cancer. 2002 Dec;3 Suppl 3:S100-8. Review.
PMID: 12533270 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Currently,
the interest in cognitive functioning following chemotherapy is
rapidly expanding as is reflected in a growing number of published
studies on this topic. Although most studies are indicativeof
cognitive deficits after chemotherapy, definite conclusions on the
role of chemotherapy on cognitive function can often not be drawn
due to methodological problems. On the basis of the studies on
cognitive functioning after chemotherapy that are conducted in The
Netherlands Cancer Institute, the current article describes a
number of such methodological topics that obscure straightforward
interpretation of neuropsychological findings in toxicity
research. Measurement issues that diverge from usual assessment
issues encountered in psychosocial oncology will be described, and
factors that might play a role in the cause of cognitive
impairment will be evaluated. Also, future developments necessary
to gain more insight into the prevalence, the pattern, and the
impact of cognitive problems following chemotherapy are discussed
Department
of Psychosocial Research and Epidemiology, The Netherlands
Cancer Institute/Antoni van Leeuwenhoek Hospital, Amsterdam.
Freeman
JR, Broshek DK.
Assessing cognitive dysfunction in breast cancer:
what are the tools?
Clin Breast
Cancer. 2002 Dec;3 Suppl 3:S91-9.
PMID: 12533269 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
The goal of
adjuvant chemotherapy in the treatment of breast cancer is to
reduce recurrence and mortality. With respect to quality of life
and morbidity, however, such treatments come at a cost. Decreased
cognitive functioning, development of fatigue, and mood
alterations are common during chemotherapy and persist after its
conclusion as evidenced by subjective self-reports and objective
neurocognitive performance records. Few efforts, however, have
used standardized neuropsychological measures, and no study has
empirically selected those measures that best distinguish women in
active chemotherapy from those who have previously completed it.
Perhaps the most glaring deficit in the literature is that no
study has used baseline data to track individual neurocognitive
changes across treatment phases and after completion. This article
provides an overview of the field of neuropsychology and the
cognitive domains theorized to be affected by chemotherapy and the
measures typically used, including validated computerized tests,
which are tools for future studies; briefly summarizes existing
research on the cognitive effects that chemotherapy has on breast
cancer patients; compares data resulting from an ongoing pilot
study of the cognitive performance of women actively undergoing
anthracycline-containing chemotherapy with that of women 6-12
months post chemotherapy completion; and provides a preliminary
analysis of the relationship between cognitive and emotional
functioning. Future uses of these data to refine the ideal tools
that efficiently, accurately, and validly detect short-term and
persistent chemotherapy effects are proposed.
Department
of Psychiatric Medicine, University of Virginia School of
Medicine, Charlottesville, USA. jf4z@virginia.edu
Ahles
TA, Saykin AJ.
Breast cancer chemotherapy-related cognitive
dysfunction.
Clin Breast
Cancer. 2002 Dec;3 Suppl 3:S84-90. Review.
PMID: 12533268 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
Cognitive
side effects of systemic chemotherapy have become an increasing
concern among breast cancer survivors, their families, and health
care professionals. A growing body of research supports the
hypothesis that chemotherapy can produce long-term cognitive
changes in at least a subgroup of cancer survivors. We review
evidence implicating systemic chemotherapy as the cause of
cognitive changes; describe the limitations due to lack of
longitudinal studies and gaps in knowledge (ie, no clear mechanism
by which chemotherapy can produce cognitive changes has been
proposed); discuss possible factors like age, intelligence
quotient/education, and psychological, genetic, and hormonal
factors that might increase risk for chemotherapy-induced
cognitive changes; and outline future directions for research.
Such future research includes large-scale, longitudinal studies of
pretreatment neuropsychological assessments, use of imaging
techniques and the development of animal models to study the
mechanisms of chemotherapy-induced changes in cognitive
functioning, and the development of interventions to prevent or
reduce the negative cognitive effects of chemotherapy
1
Department of Psychiatry and Center for Psycho-Oncology
Research, Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, NH
03756, USA. tim.a.ahles@dartmouth.edu
Schagen
SB, Muller MJ, Boogerd W, Rosenbrand RM, van Rhijn D, Rodenhuis S,
van Dam FS.
Late effects of adjuvant chemotherapy on cognitive
function: a follow-up study in breast cancer patients.
Ann
Oncol. 2002 Sep;13(9):1387-97.
PMID: 12196364 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
BACKGROUND:
Neuropsychological examinations have shown an elevated risk for
cognitive impairment 2 years after therapy in breast cancer
patients randomized to receive adjuvant high-dose cyclophosphamide,
thiotepa, carboplatin (CTC) chemotherapy compared with a
non-treated control group of stage I breast cancer patients.
Patients randomized to receive standard-dose fluorouracil,
epirubicin, cyclophosphamide (FEC) chemotherapy showed no elevated
risk compared with controls. However, breast cancer patients
treated with conventional cyclophosphamide, methotrexate,
5-fluorouracil (CMF) chemotherapy showed a higher risk of
cognitive impairment. The present study was designed to obtain a
greater insight into these long-term neuropsychological sequelae
following chemotherapy and their course in time. PATIENTS AND
METHODS: At 4 years post-therapy, 22 of the original 34 CTC
patients, 23 of 36 FEC patients, 31 of 39 CMF patients and 27 of
34 control patients were re-examined with neuropsychological
tests. RESULTS: Improvement in performance was observed in all
chemotherapy groups, whereas in the control group there was a
slight deterioration in test results. A differential attrition was
observed among the groups, with a relatively high percentage of
initially cognitively impaired patients from the CTC group
dropping out due to factors related to disease progression.
CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that cognitive dysfunction
following adjuvant chemotherapy in breast cancer patients may be
transient. Additional studies are needed to investigate the
differential attrition of patients with cognitive impairment.
Department
of Psychosocial Research and Epidemiology, The Netherlands
Cancer Institute/Antoni van Leeuwenhoek Hospital, Amsterdam,
The Netherlands.
Harder
H, Cornelissen JJ, Van Gool AR, Duivenvoorden HJ, Eijkenboom WM,
van den Bent MJ.
Cognitive functioning and quality of life in
long-term adult survivors of bone marrow transplantation.
BACKGROUND:
The late neurotoxic effects of bone marrow transplantation (BMT)
on cognitive functioning and quality of life (QOL) were
investigated in a consecutively treated cohort of long-term adult
survivors. METHODS: Progression-free patients treated with BMT or
peripheral stem cell grafts for a hematologic malignancy at least
2 years before study participation were examined with a
comprehensive battery of neuropsychological tests and
questionnaires for QOL and mood states. The results of the
neuropsychological tests were compared with healthy population
norms. RESULTS: Forty patients were included, 87.5% of whom had
undergone an allogeneic transplantation. All received total body
irradiation up to 12 Gy (in two fractions). Assessment took place
22-82 months after BMT. Mild to moderate cognitive impairment was
found in 24 patients (60%). Compared with healthy population
norms, selective attention and executive function, information
processing speed, verbal learning, and verbal and visual memory
were most likely to be affected. The mean score for the total
patient group revealed that these patients scored significantly
lower on the information processing speed task compared with
expected scores obtained from the normal population. The main
predictors for poor neuropsychological performance were fatigue,
global health, and educational level. Other correlations with
moderate to severe cognitive impairment were subjective cognitive
complaints, physical functioning, social functioning, overall mood
states, and employment status. CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate
that BMT may lead to cognitive complaints and late cognitive
deficits in long-term adult survivors. Cognitive functioning
should therefore be used as an outcome parameter in BMT studies.
Copyright 2002 American Cancer Society.
Department
of Neuro-Oncology, University Hospital Rotterdam/Daniel den
Hoed Cancer Center, Rotterdam, The Netherlands. harder@hemh.azr.nl
Kingma
A, Van Dommelen RI, Mooyaart EL, Wilmink JT, Deelman BG, Kamps WA.
No major cognitive impairment in young children with
acute lymphoblastic leukemia using chemotherapy only: a
prospective longitudinal study.
PURPOSE: To
study, using serial neuropsychological assessment and evaluation
of school achievement, persistent neuropsychological late effects
in children treated for acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) at a
young age with chemotherapy only. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Twenty
consecutive patients underwent three evaluations, including 12
psychometric measures beside IQ. The authors applied strict
methodology and a prospective-longitudinal design that started at
diagnosis and extended to a median follow-up of 7 years. This
report focuses on the outcome of the last evaluation. Test results
were compared with healthy controls and to patients with ALL
treated on a previous chemotherapy-only protocol. School
achievement was evaluated in patients and their siblings. RESULTS:
At the last evaluation, significantly lower test scores in
patients compared with controls were found for only 2 of 14
cognitive measures (1 intelligence and 1 attention measure). No
great differences were seen between school achievement of patients
and siblings. Compared with the previous chemotherapy protocol, a
better outcome was seen in the current study group on two measures
(one memory and one attention measure). CONCLUSIONS: Children
surviving ALL have no major cognitive impairment after
chemotherapy, including intrathecal and high-dose intravenous
methotrexate. The slightly better outcome in the current group may
indicate possible adverse effects of more dexamethasone treatment
in the previous group.
Department
of Pediatrics, University Hospital Groningen, The Netherlands.
a.kingma@bkk.azg.nl
Neuropsychologic impact of standard-dose systemic
chemotherapy in long-term survivors of breast cancer and lymphoma.
J
Clin Oncol. 2002 Jan 15;20(2):485-93.
PMID: 11786578 [PubMed - indexed for MEDLINE]
PURPOSE:
The primary purpose of this study was to compare the neuropsychologic
functioning of long-term survivors of breast cancer and lymphoma
who had been treated with standard-dose systemic chemotherapy or local
therapy only. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Long-term survivors (5 years postdiagnosis,
not presently receiving cancer treatment, and disease-free) of
breast cancer or lymphoma who had been treated with systemic
chemotherapy (breast
cancer: n = 35, age, 59.1 +/- 10.7 years; lymphoma: n = 36, age, 55.9
+/- 12.1 years) or local therapy only (breast cancer: n = 35, age,
60.6 +/-
10.5 years; lymphoma: n = 22, age, 48.7 +/- 11.7 years) completed
a battery
of neuropsychologic and psychologic tests (Center for Epidemiological
Study-Depression, Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, and
Fatigue Symptom Inventory). RESULTS: Multivariate analysis of
variance, controlling
for age and education, revealed that survivors who had been treated
with systemic chemotherapy scored significantly lower on the
battery of
neuropsychologic tests compared with those treated with local
therapy only
(P <.04), particularly in the domains of verbal memory (P
<.01) and psychomotor
functioning (P <.03). Survivors treated with systemic chemotherapy
were also more likely to score in the lower quartile on the Neuropsychological
Performance Index (39% v 14%, P <.01) and to self-report greater
problems with working memory on the Squire Memory Self-Rating Questionnaire
(P <.02). CONCLUSION: Data from this study support the hypothesis
that systemic chemotherapy can have a negative impact on cognitive
functioning as measured by standardized neuropsychologic tests and
self-report
of memory changes. However, analysis of the Neuropsychological Performance
Index suggests that only a subgroup of survivors may experience long-term
cognitive deficits associated with systemic chemotherapy.
1
Department of Psychiatry and Center for Psycho-Oncology
Research, Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, Lebanon, NH
03756, USA. tim.a.ahles@dartmouth.edu
Note
If
you experience symptoms of chemobrain, I strongly encourage
you to talk with your health care professional about your
specific medical condition and treatments. The information
contained in this web site is meant to be helpful and
educational, but is not a substitute for medical advice.
If you
feel your medical team is not informed or supportive about
chemobrain, I urge you to refer them to this web site or seek
out a provider among those listed who are actively engaged in
the research and writing on this complex matter.